Liberal evangelical personality Tony Campolo recently shocked no one by formally announcing his approval of monogamous gay marriage, coupled with a plea that other Christians do the same. A more surprising similar announcement came almost simultaneously from former Christianity Today editor David Neff on Facebook. The latter put conservative Evangelical "thought leaders" on social media into a relative state of disarray, and Christianity Today issued a response to the whole ordeal aptly titled, "Breaking news: 2 billion Christians believe in traditional marriage." It's worth reading both Campolo's announcement and CT's response. However there's a disconnect between the two, in that while Campolo makes an essentially emotional and cultural appeal, CT responds primarily with theology. As appropriate and important as such a theological response is, there's a problem with Campolo's reasoning--and hence the reasoning of the larger Christian community that has become sympathetic to gay marriage--that goes untouched. Although the title of the CT article hints at the problem, the writer doesn't expound on it in his piece. That problem is the narrow, cyclical nature of Campolo and Company's "cultural" self-evaluation. ![]() The late Orthodox priest and seminary dean Fr. Alexander Schmemann had some thoughts about Western cultural self-evaluation when once asked about the Episcopal Church's then burgeoning controversy over the priestly ordination of women. Though the provoking issue was different, his observations about typical Western reasoning on these issues has relevance for today's latest cultural flash point of gay marriage. Here's an excerpt below, in which I've replaced every mention of "women's ordination" with "gay marriage," so as to bring Schmemann's point about the overall Western mindset into better focus without distracting on the topic of women's ordination (emphases my own). The debate on [gay marriage] reveals something which we have suspected for a long time but which now is confirmed beyond any doubt: the total, truly built-in indifference of the Christian West to anything beyond the sphere of its own problematics, of its own experience. I can only repeat here what I have said before: even the so-called "ecumenical movement," notwithstanding its claims to the contrary, has always been, and still is, a purely Western phenomenon, based on Western presuppositions and determined by a specifically Western agenda. This is not "pride" or "arrogance." On the contrary, the Christian West is almost obsessed with a guilt complex and enjoys nothing better than self-criticism and self condemnation. It is rather a total inability to transcend itself, to accept the simple idea that its own experience, problems, thought forms and priorities may not be universal, that they themselves may need to be evaluated and judged in the light of a truly universal, truly "Catholic" experience. Western Christians would almost enthusiastically judge and condemn themselves, but on their own terms and within their own hopelessly "Western" perspective. Thus when they decide -- on the basis of their own "cultural situation" -- that they must "repair" injustices to [gay and lesbian persons], they plan to do it immediately without even asking what the "others" may think about it, and are sincerely amazed and even saddened by the lack on the part of these "others" of ecumenical spirit, sympathy, and comprehension. Personally, I would expect Schmemann's angle on these issues to be a non-starter with a culture so deeply and hopelessly obsessed with itself as ours. But it would behoove historically grounded Christians engaging culture on gay marriage not to concede the purity of the Western moral guilt complex at the outset. Two billion Christians would appreciate it.
0 Comments
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Categories
All
Archives
August 2020
Orthodox MiscellanyOrthodox Intro
Ancient Faith Publishing St. Vlad's Seminary Press St. Tikhon's Monastery Press New Rome Press Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy Roads from Emmaus Fr Patrick Henry Reardon Orthodox Synaxis Orthodox-Reformed Bridge Everyday Asceticism Lux Christi Orthodox Arts Journal Pageau Carvings Glory to God for All Things Classical Christianity The Music Stand The Whole Counsel Blog Molly Sabourin Theoria Paracletos Monastery Icons Antiochian Archdiocese Orthodox Church in America The Orthodox West Assembly of Bishops St. Tikhon's Seminary St Vladimir's Seminary Trinity College St. Basil Center Orthodox Christians for Life FOCUS North America Orthodox Volunteer Corps Project Mexico Burning Bush Coffee Politikos |